So I was able to watch the 20/20 piece by Elizabeth Vargas… and while there was some accurate information (The US being, pretty much, the only country that does NOT offer paid benefits for new moms, both Iran and North Korea have better plans, granted I do not want to live in those countries), I found this piece to be shockingly lacking (and shockingly short). Noone talked about the new moms who are forced from there jobs because childcare is much more than their paycheck and have to pick up government assistance. Noone talked about the middle class who are struggling with their 2 parent incomes and raising a child. What about the single moms (I dont know how you girls do it, kudos to you!) who have to work more than one job just to scrape by? What about moms that are denied employment just because they are moms?
I am really glad this piece was aired, but so much was not even touched. I can only hope this is just the beginning.
I am shocked by all the comments on the 20/20 message boards. I did choose to have a child, while some choose not to, yes, my choice. Would you rather I became a productive member positively contributing to our economy or would you prefer that I live on government assistance and food stamps that you pay for with your taxes?
Los Angeles-based radio talk-show host Tom Leykis just railed about how woman should just stay home and it isnt HIS responsibility to help anyone (clearly not looking at the bigger picture), the amount of people who agree with him is astounding to me. One woman called in to say that, “Maybe they should leave their childbearing uterus at home. Why work?” .. WOW.
and THEN.. there is Karen Czarnecki, deputy assistant secretary of labor. She said, and I am quoting here…
“I think mandating such benefits across employers of all kinds will hurt our economy,” she said. “We’d end up losing jobs. I really think the economic consequences would be dire.”
WOW
I actually believe the opposite. I believe that with 71% of all mothers in this country working, the economy would come to a grinding halt without us. I believe that if this country and our businesses were more family friendly we would boost our economy with happier, harder working moms.
We are a country that continuously talks about family values, yet government policies and the lack of discussion about these problems say quite the opposite. They say “sure, have your baby, but just stay home because we’re not going to help you recover and prepare to return to the work force and become an active member and contributor to our economy, we just dont care about you, but please, have more kids because thats what you should do”
Most of us.. CAN’T stay home.. and certainly can’t stay home without substantial government assistance. So which is better? Bettering the benefits and day care assistance, or forcing productive, smart, hardworking women out of the workforce only to have the govenment spend MORE on assistance to help us when we cant work? Moms are also being denied employment because they have kids, many just because they are “of child bearing age” (umm so 18-45 year olds?).. and this is legal discrimination.
They also mentioned a group called ChildFree. I just wanted to mention that I know plenty of couples that choose to be child free .. that is what they want and they have every right to choose that route.. but my child free friends also respect and applaud my choices, as I respect theirs. We hear words like “Freedom” bantered about and part of that freedom is the right to choose, not the right-to-choose-but-you-will-be-punished-for-making-the-wrong-choice (wrong being defined here as the opposite of what whatever choice the accuser has made).
I made the choice to bring a beautiful boy into this world and I believe I (just me here folks, I am only speaking about myself, I cannot speak for others on this statement) am a better mom to him because I have a passion for my work and that teaches him to work hard at the things he loves and to become an active member of society. My choice is that he can grow up in a real family friendly America.
To view the ABC piece go Here. For more information please visit Moms Rising.
I, too, was surprised at how short the piece was: I started out hopeful when I realised it was to be the first (main? ...or not) piece, and couldn’t quite believe it when it was over. And, then, considering how brief it all was, there was an awful lot of campy soundtrack taking up airtime...but that’s one girl’s opinion
The whole piece left me with a feeling of yeah, but what can we do, really resignation - likely made all the more prominent by clips like the radio talk show host and his listeners.
It was good to see the piece aired but, I agree, it could have been so much more.
Now, I have to get the mindset together before braving the 20/20 forums…
Beware Jenn, they are brutal.
I have not seen the 20/20 piece, but I think I might be glad about that.
It makes me very angry to think about the Family Values bit Lizzie speaks of.
I think it’s really easy for people to march around saying that This is family value and That is a family value. Then turn around and say that Welfare Moms should just get a job… As a country, we absolutely DO NOT support working mothers. 12 weeks maternity leave is barely enough--and forget it if you’re breastfeeding. And then, once you’re back to work after having your baby, I think a lot of working Moms feel as though they are being monitored and watched--I know that I felt watched when I came back. Further, several colleagues--including management--acted as though I’d just enjoyed a nice 12-week paid vacation.
So on top of getting Washington to recognize and support the value of family, working Moms still have battle a secret stigma when the DO return to work.
When I hear Bush touting the decline in unemployment, I know that the majority of those “new jobs” are minimum wage positions in service industries. I wish I had percentage for how many of those folks were working mothers--trying to support their families on minimum wage.
And the whole business of legislating breastfeeding? Well. How can we do that when our major employers don’t support working families.


It’s sickening that a country that touts itself as “Leader of the Free World” has such a pathetic view on the role of mothers in the workforce.